ZDNet News ZDNet Sites:  Reviews | Downloads | Business | Prices 

Free Downloads · Find Tech Jobs 
Page OneHardwareSoftwareNetworkingE-CommerceCommentary


COMMENTARY STORY: Guest IT workers aren't the Net police

TalkBack! By Jeff Moad
August 20, 2001 5:57 AM PT
COMMENTARY--It looks like the now-infamous case of until recently jailed Russian software developer Dmitry Sklyarov was just the beginning of a broader trend to cast IT professionals in the role of info cop. Software developers like Sklyarov and even help desk and system administration workers, it appears, are being deputized to enforce ill-conceived laws aimed at perceived Web-borne threats to society.

Sklyarov was thrown into jail for failing to police and censor his own software development decisions. As has been widely reported, Sklyarov was jailed in mid-July for having developed software that could make it easier for users of Adobe's eBook Reader to disable security features that restricted how eBook content could be accessed. Although the application apparently violated no Russian law, it did, according to the Justice Department, run afoul of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, or DMCA, which bans technologies that could be used to get around software used to protect digital copyrighted material. Sklyarov was recently released on bail, and the case is still pending.

The same week Sklyarov was jailed, the state of South Carolina added IT workers to the list of professionals required to report to legal authorities if, in the course of attending to a piece of technology, they see-say on a PC hard drive-that the user has collected child pornography or other evidence of child abuse or neglect. There are penalties for IT workers who fail to report such evidence to authorities but, reportedly, few if any guidelines on specifically what constitutes reportable evidence.

The urge to enlist IT workers and software developers in the battle against what seem like new threats enabled by the Web is, I supposed, not surprising. To many legislators and government lawyers, the workings of the Web seem complex. Who better to spot bad guys and prevent harmful technologies from seeing the light of day than the tech experts themselves?

But a closer look suggests that turning IT types into digital cops makes no sense. Take the Sklyarov case, for example. Asking legitimate, commercial developers like Sklyarov not to develop software that could be used to skirt technology used to protect copyrighted material could, in the end, do more to harm the security of products like eBook than to protect it. If Sklyarov can develop and distribute software that can bypass the eBook protections, you can be sure underground hackers can and will do much worse. The smart thing would be to use what developers like Sklyarov have written to learn how to improve security software rather than asking him and other above-ground developers to police and censor themselves.

Flawed logic
The logic behind enlisting IT tech support workers in the war against digitally distributed child pornography is similarly flawed. In the vast majority of instances, tech support workers would have no reason to look at the type of content contained in Web history files on a user's PC. Asking them to do so would be like asking automobile mechanics to examine the contents of customers' vehicles in search of illegal drugs or guns. Bad guys are known to transport bad stuff in the trunks of their cars, right? So, while mechanics are under the hood, why not ask them to take a peek into the trunk? While we're at it, why don't we ask dry cleaners to report if they uncover lipstick-smeared shirts that show a husband has been unfaithful to his spouse? The whole thing smacks a bit too much of Cultural Revolution-style invasion of privacy.

Don't get me wrong. I think destructive hackers must be stopped. Same for people who exploit children. I'm just saying that enlisting software developers and IT workers as the front-line troops in those battles, in the end, makes no sense. What makes more sense is to use existing laws to go after these people. We have existing copyright laws that, unlike the DMCA, actually target copyright-infringing behaviors, not the tools that enable them. Likewise, we have anti-child pornography laws that permit hard disk searches upon the presentation of probable cause. Why not use them?

What do you think? Should IT professionals be enlisted as info cops? Let me know in the TalkBack below.

E-mail this story!
Printer Friendly

Also on ZDNet
  FREE! Get IT downloads from TechRepublic.
  Get certified -- SmartPlanet helps you learn more online
  Stay current on biz tech topics with free e-mail newsletters.
  Browse through more than 300,000 articles
  Check out PCs, handhelds, CD burners, and more in the College Buying Guide.

Sound Off

Talkback: Post your comment here
My my... sounds just like Hitle... - M Lurk
This will open the doors for lo... - Glen Silvia
Why not? Heck, we are asking c... - John Carroll
I think you're preaching to the... - anonymous coward
I work as a student employee of... - Mark Ordonez
About 15-20 years ago, I (I... - Jim Cassilly
[Leave it to John Carrol to... - freehand
As adults do we need more pryin... - Brandy Alexander
John, at times I think that you... - Kimball Kinnison
To Kimball Kinnison, you sent m... - John Carroll
"So now programmers have to wor... - Byron Hadley
big business can only get so bi... - James Casey
Economists support antitrust la... - Chris
I know a few IT buddies that th... - Dan Freider

This story originally appeared in eWEEK.


search for


Coop's Corner

Is it time to end the H-1B program?
Silicon Valley loved the H-1B visa program, which lets companies import engineers and other tech pros from overseas. That worked out great when jobs were going unfilled, but with the economy down and layoffs up, some Americans say the foreigners need to go. If only it were that easy, says David Coursey.

TalkBack Central

TalkBack Central A page dedicated entirely to you and your views!

Is Windows XP really ready to roll?

Posters' IDs can stay under wraps

IBM ditches AMD in North America

News Tools

  News Archives

  News in Brief

  News for your PDA

  Contact us



ZDNet News brings you a summary of top headlines each business day.


 Sponsored Links
GoDaddy  It's True! Domain Names and Transfers $8.95/yr & lower.
MICRON PC  Millennia MAX XS. 1.3GHz, 128MB, 40GB, printer, $1199.
Got Power?  When blackouts roll in roll out APC! Win UPS!
Autoweb  Dealers must reduce inventory-all 2001 models must go!
Books  Free Shipping at Barnes & Noble.com!
EARN MORE  Advance your career with University of Phoenix Online.

 Everything Intel    Find Out More
Shop Now!   Shop at Dell's Home Solution Center - Dell Small Business Center
Shop Now!   Gateway Home Computing Center - TOSHIBA
Shop Now   Gateway Business Center

 Featured Links
Best Buys  Shop Smart for scanners, digital cameras, monitors & more!
Save Now  SAVE Money! Buy it Refurbished or New at Half.com.
FREE!  Tech Advice and 100's of Downloads for IT Pros!

 Magazine Offers
2 FREE CDs  Try Computer Shopper FREE ($3.99 value)- & Get 2 FREE CDs

ZDNet Free Membership | Free E-mail | Newsletters | PC Updates  | Careers

Support | Privacy | Terms of Use | Advertise | About Us

Copyright © 2001 ZD Inc. ZDNet is a registered service mark of ZD Inc. ZDNet Logo is a service mark of ZD Inc.

Copyright 2001 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved. ZDNet is a registered service mark of CNET Networks, Inc. ZDNet Logo is service mark of CNET Networks, Inc. Content originally published in Ziff Davis Media publications is the copyrighted property of Ziff Davis Media. Copyright 2001 Ziff Davis Media. All rights reserved. Titles of Ziff Davis Media publications are trademarks of Ziff Davis Publishing Holdings Inc.